Instructions
Article Highlights
|
A cookie decorating party is an easy way to bring everyone together during the holiday season, and everyone leaves with something delicious to show for it. With a little prep, a batch (or two) of cookies and plenty of colorful McCormick® Food Colors, you can create a festive afternoon or evening that’s just as much fun for the host as it is for the guests.
The secret is doing most of the baking and setup before everyone arrives. From choosing the right cookie recipes and preparing icing ahead of time to organizing your decorating station, these tips will help you host a holiday gathering that runs smoothly from the first cookie to the last sprinkle.
Choose a Theme for Your Cookie Decorating Party
Start by deciding what kind of party you want to host. A classic Christmas theme can include trees, snowflakes, ornaments and gingerbread people, but holiday cookie decorating doesn’t have to stop at red and green. Try an icy winter palette, a gingerbread theme or a colorful cookie bar where guests can create whatever they like.
Hosting kids? Keep the shapes and decorations simple, with plenty of sprinkles and easy-to-use icing. For adults, set up a more elevated cookie bar with a curated color palette, piping bags and a few decorating examples for inspiration. The same idea can also work for birthdays and other celebrations throughout the year.
Keep the guest list manageable enough that everyone has room to decorate. Around two hours gives guests time to settle in, decorate several cookies and enjoy snacks and drinks without feeling rushed. A sit-down format works well for a smaller group, while an open-house or drop-in setup can make hosting a larger crowd easier.
Your theme can also help keep the budget in check. Instead of offering every possible sprinkle, icing color and cookie shape, choose a few coordinating options and let guests mix and match them.
Bake Your Cookies Ahead of Time
The day of the party should be about decorating, not waiting for baking sheets to come out of the oven. Bake your cookies at least a day ahead so they're completely cool and ready for cookie decoration when guests arrive.
Spiced Holiday Sugar Cookies are a great base for a decorating party. McCormick Ground Cinnamon, Ground Nutmeg and All Natural Pure Vanilla Extract add warm holiday flavor to the dough, while the cookies can be cut into trees, stars, snowflakes or any other seasonal shapes, and decorated with McCormick Food Coloring. Roll the dough to an even 1/4-inch thickness and bake just until the edges begin to lightly brown so the finished cookies are sturdy enough to decorate without becoming too crisp.
For another holiday classic, Gingerbread Men Cookies combine McCormick Ground Ginger, Ground Cinnamon, Ground Nutmeg, molasses and McCormick All Natural Pure Vanilla Extract. The dough can be refrigerated overnight, making it especially convenient for party prep. Cut traditional gingerbread people or use other holiday cookie cutters, then let guests add icing, candies or their own creative details.
Want to add a few more cookies to your holiday spread? 7 Easy Cookie Recipes to Feel Like a Baking Pro has plenty of inspiration, while The Best Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipes can help you add a familiar favorite for guests to snack on between decorating rounds.
Make Your Icing in Advance
A good icing setup makes it much easier for guests to experiment with different cookie decorating ideas.
Colorful Royal Icing is especially useful for detailed designs because it dries firm and glossy. McCormick All Natural Pure Vanilla Extract adds flavor to the icing, while McCormick Assorted Food Colors and Neon Food Colors make it easy to create a palette that fits your party theme.
Consistency matters depending on how you plan to decorate. Keep royal icing thicker for piping outlines and fine details, or thin it gradually with small amounts of water for flooding larger areas of the cookie. Keep any icing you're not actively using covered, so it doesn't begin to dry out.
Buttercream is another option if you want a softer, creamier finish. It works especially well for kids and casual decorating because guests can spread it onto cookies with a small offset spatula or butter knife before adding sprinkles and candies. Flavor either style of icing with vanilla or experiment with extracts such as peppermint, almond, orange or lemon to give different colors their own flavor.
Cookies can be baked ahead and stored in an airtight container once completely cool. Prepare icing in advance as well, keeping it tightly covered until you're ready to use it. If you're transporting everything to another location, pack cookies in sturdy containers with parchment between layers and carry icings separately.
Set Up a Cookie Decorating Station
A little organization keeps a cookie decorating party from turning into a table covered in open icing bags and runaway sprinkles.
Instead of putting everything in one spot, create a natural flow across the table. Start with undecorated cookies and plates, followed by icing, decorating tools and sprinkles. Leave an open area at the end where guests can place completed cookies to dry.
For supplies, have several piping bags, small piping tips, offset spatulas or butter knives, small bowls, spoons, parchment paper and plenty of napkins available. Disposable piping bags make cleanup easier, while resealable plastic bags with a tiny corner snipped off work well when you need additional colors without buying more decorating tools.
Divide sprinkles, sanding sugars and candies into small bowls rather than setting out their original containers. This makes them easier to share and helps prevent one accidental shake from covering the entire table.
Label icing flavors and colors, especially if you're using different extracts. Clearly mark any ingredients that contain common allergens, and keep allergy-friendly cookies, icing and decorating tools separate to help reduce cross-contact. Individual decorating kits are another easy option for children or guests with specific dietary needs.
Finally, cover the table with parchment paper or another disposable covering before the party begins. You'll be very happy you did once the sprinkles start flying.
Try a Few Easy Cookie Decorating Techniques
You don’t need professional piping skills to create beautiful holiday cookies. Set out a few examples or demonstrate one or two beginner-friendly techniques at the start of the party, then let everyone get creative.
Flooding is a great place to start. Pipe an outline around the edge of the cookie with thicker royal icing, then fill the center with a slightly thinner consistency. For a wet-on-wet design, add dots, stripes or another color of icing while the base layer is still wet. Dragging a toothpick through the colors creates hearts, swirls, feathers and other simple patterns.
Marbling is another forgiving technique. Add a few drops or lines of contrasting icing to a wet base, then gently swirl them together with a toothpick.
For kids, keep cookie decorating ideas playful and easy: snowman faces, colorful ornaments, sprinkle-covered trees and gingerbread people with candy buttons. Adults can experiment with more detailed snowflakes, piped borders, monograms or a coordinated color palette.
Edible color and flavor extracts offer another way to customize the cookies. Tint royal icing in several shades using McCormick Food Colors, then give different colors their own flavor with vanilla, peppermint, almond, lemon or orange extract. Since extracts vary in intensity, start with a small amount and add more as needed.
Serve Simple Snacks and Drinks
There will already be plenty of cookies on the table, so keep the rest of the party menu simple. Savory snacks, cheese and crackers, fresh fruit, popcorn or a small appetizer spread give guests something to enjoy between cookies.
For drinks, serve coffee, hot chocolate, tea or apple cider. A hot chocolate bar can double as another party activity: set out marshmallows, crushed peppermint candies and homemade whipped cream so guests can customize their mugs.
If you want another easy holiday treat that doesn’t require decorating, make a batch of bark ahead of time. These Easy Holiday Bark Recipes offer plenty of festive options for the snack table or take-home boxes.
Turn Finished Cookies into Party Favors
Part of the fun of a cookie decorating party is sending everyone home with their creations. Set out small bakery boxes, tins or food-safe bags so guests can package their cookies once the icing is completely dry.
You can also create simple favor kits with an undecorated cookie or two, a small bag of sprinkles and a recipe card so guests can continue decorating at home. For an extra holiday touch, include a small spice sachet with cinnamon, ginger or nutmeg to inspire their next batch of holiday cookie recipes.
Not every activity has to involve food, either. A holiday coloring station, printable activity sheets or ornament decorating can keep younger guests entertained while cookies dry. These are especially helpful if you’re hosting families with children of different ages.
Plan Ahead for Stress-Free Hosting
A little advance prep goes a long way when you’re hosting holiday cookie decorating. Rather than trying to bake, make icing and set up the party on the same day, spread the work over a few days.
2 to 3 days before: Shop for ingredients and decorating supplies, make cookie dough that requires chilling, gather cookie cutters and serving pieces, and organize take-home packaging.
1 day before: Bake the Spiced Holiday Sugar Cookies and Gingerbread Men Cookies and let them cool completely before storing. Prepare royal icing and organize sprinkles, candies and other decorations.
A few hours before: Set up the decorating table, divide icing into colors, fill piping bags, arrange decorating supplies and prepare snacks and beverages. Keep cookies covered until you're ready to place them at the station.
When guests arrive: Give everyone a plate or workspace and briefly explain where everything is. If you're demonstrating techniques, do it early before guests begin decorating.
During the party: Refill supplies as needed, wipe up spills and make sure finished cookies have a designated place to dry.
Before guests leave: Make sure the icing has had enough time to set before packaging cookies. If some designs are still wet, send guests home with their cookies in a single layer rather than stacking them.
Troubleshoot Common Cookie Decorating Problems
Even with plenty of preparation, a few decorating mishaps are inevitable — and usually easy to fix.
If royal icing is too thick, add water a few drops at a time until you reach the desired consistency. If it becomes too thin, gradually mix in additional confectioners’ sugar.
If icing begins drying before guests use it, keep bowls covered and avoid filling piping bags too far in advance. Royal icing exposed to air can develop a crust quickly.
Cookies that spread during baking can lose the crisp shapes that make decorating easier. Keep the dough at the recommended thickness and follow the chilling instructions for your chosen cookie recipes.
And don't worry about making every cookie picture-perfect. A decorating party is much more fun when guests feel free to experiment rather than trying to recreate a professional design.
Make Cleanup Part of the Plan
The easiest cleanup starts before the party. Cover your decorating surface with parchment or a disposable table covering and use small bowls to contain sprinkles and candies. Keep a trash bowl or small bin nearby for empty piping bags, paper towels and other scraps.
Once the party ends, discard or store leftover decorating ingredients, wipe down tools and package any remaining cookies. Fully dried decorated cookies can be stored in an airtight container, with parchment between layers if needed to protect the designs.
Extra plain cookies don't have to go to waste, either. Freeze them for another decorating day or package them with leftover icing and sprinkles for an easy at-home activity.
Make Holiday Cookie Decorating a Tradition
Whether you're hosting kids for an afternoon of sprinkles and gingerbread people or setting up an adults-only cookie bar with festive drinks and elevated designs, the goal is the same: make it easy for everyone to create something delicious, spend time together and have fun in the process. And with a little planning, your holiday cookie party might just become a tradition everyone looks forward to each year.
